The Theories
Explore

The Theories

From the Treasure of the Knights Templar to Shakespeare's lost manuscripts.

38 theories

Medieval Connections

Warrior monks, early adventurers, and the forensic evidence they left behind

The Knights Templar

The Knights Templar

Who were the Knights Templar and what evidence is there for their presence on Oak Island? From warrior monks of the Crusades to the powerful force behind Oak Island's deepest mystery.

10 min read
The Knights Hospitaller

The Knights Hospitaller

Often overshadowed by the Templars, the Knights Hospitaller were equally powerful and far longer ...

4 min read
The Knights of Malta

The Knights of Malta

From the fortress of Malta to the shores of Nova Scotia. The Knights of Malta held a fleet, gover...

6 min read
De Villiers: The Treasure Bloodline

De Villiers: The Treasure Bloodline

One family. Ten generations. From the Templar escape of 1307 to the shores of Nova Scotia in 1632...

9 min read
Oak Island Mystery Trees

Oak Island Mystery Trees

The trees that gave Oak Island its name were never oaks. Forensic botanical analysis identifies t...

9 min read
Zena Halpern and the Templar Map of Oak Island

Zena Halpern and the Templar Map of Oak Island

New York researcher Zena Halpern brought three documents to The Curse of Oak Island that reshaped...

14 min read
The Portuguese: The Order of Christ

The Portuguese: The Order of Christ

The Templar order never died. It was reborn in Portugal, and its knights sailed to the New World.

7 min read

Explorers and Expeditions

From Norse longships to Roosevelt's private letters

Vikings

Vikings

Norse explorers reached Nova Scotia centuries before Columbus. Could Viking expeditions explain Oak Island's earliest construction and what lies below?

6 min read
The Roosevelt Connection

The Roosevelt Connection

Franklin D. Roosevelt's Oak Island obsession spanned thirty-six years, from a boyhood visit to th...

13 min read
The Doomed Expedition of the Duc d'Anville

The Doomed Expedition of the Duc d'Anville

In 1746, France assembled the largest fleet ever sent to the New World: 64 ships and 11,000 men u...

14 min read
Henry Sinclair, the Zeno voyage

Henry Sinclair, the Zeno voyage

In 1398, a Scottish earl and two Venetian navigators allegedly sailed west. They may have reached...

9 min read
William Phips, the Treasure of the Concepción

William Phips, the Treasure of the Concepción

Could a 17th-century treasure hunter, a sunken Spanish galleon, and a conspiracy to overthrow a k...

8 min read

Pirates and Privateers

Captain Kidd, Blackbeard, and a dying pirate's cryptogram

Pirates

Pirates

Captain Kidd, Blackbeard, Henry Every, and Peter Easton. Oak Island sits in Mahone Bay, a documented pirate haven where crews recruited, resupplied, and disappeared for over a century.

7 min read
Peter Easton, the Pirate Admiral

Peter Easton, the Pirate Admiral

The wealthiest pirate of his era commanded 40 ships from Newfoundland, captured a Spanish silver ...

7 min read
Captain Kidd and the Hidden Maps

Captain Kidd and the Hidden Maps

The oldest theory and the name that started it all. A privateer's commission, a dying sailor's co...

11 min read
La Buse and the Unsolved Cryptogram

La Buse and the Unsolved Cryptogram

In 1730, French pirate Olivier Levasseur threw a coded message into the crowd at his execution an...

10 min read
Blackbeard, the Devil's Bargain

Blackbeard, the Devil's Bargain

The most feared pirate of the Golden Age claimed he buried his treasure "where none but Satan and...

6 min read

Secret Societies

Freemasons, Rosicrucians, and the manuscripts of Francis Bacon

William Shakespeare, the Lost Works

William Shakespeare, the Lost Works

Four researchers using different methods each decoded directions in Shakespeare's works pointing to Oak Island. Then the drilling began to prove them right.

13 min read
Francis Bacon's Secret Island

Francis Bacon's Secret Island

He invented the biliteral cipher, described a tidal seawater pit in his published works, and held...

14 min read
Rosicrusians

Rosicrusians

The Rosicrucian manifestos of 1614 described a sealed underground vault built to survive centurie...

9 min read
Early Freemasons

Early Freemasons

Masonic symbols, geometric design, and secretive construction. How early Freemasonry's documented...

10 min read

Colonial Powers and Hidden Wealth

Empires clashed over Nova Scotia, and fortunes vanished

The Sack of Havana

The Sack of Havana

In 1762, British forces captured Havana and seized a fortune in Spanish gold, silver, and warships. Did rogue officers divert part of that treasure to Oak Island on their way north to Halifax?

9 min read
The Knights Baronet

The Knights Baronet

Nova Scotia was created as a baronetcy in 1621. The Knights Baronet held direct authority over Oa...

9 min read
The Treasure of St. Andrew's Cathedral

The Treasure of St. Andrew's Cathedral

Scotland's greatest cathedral held a thousand years of sacred wealth. In 1559, it all vanished.

9 min read
The Secret British Military Bank

The Secret British Military Bank

Between 1749 and 1783, Nova Scotia was the most strategically contested territory in the British ...

10 min read
Spanish Galleons full of Inca Gold

Spanish Galleons full of Inca Gold

Between 1500 and 1650, Spain extracted 181 tons of gold and 16,000 tons of silver from the Americ...

10 min read
The Treasure of Louisbourg

The Treasure of Louisbourg

For twenty-five years, France poured a fortune into the Fortress of Louisbourg, building the migh...

11 min read
The Jewels of Marie Antoinette

The Jewels of Marie Antoinette

When Marie Antoinette prepared to flee revolutionary Paris in 1791, she packed her diamonds, pear...

9 min read

Geometry, Alignments and Symbolism

Star maps, sacred geometry, and lines drawn across continents

The Versailles Alignment to Oak Island

The Versailles Alignment to Oak Island

A giant Menorah hidden in the gardens of Versailles points directly to the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, and to Oak Island.

14 min read
Nicolas Poussin, Keeper of Secrets

Nicolas Poussin, Keeper of Secrets

Nicolas Poussin painted secret knowledge into his masterpieces. Two of his works, read together, ...

16 min read
Jean Richer, the Astronomer Sent to Acadia

Jean Richer, the Astronomer Sent to Acadia

In 1670, a French astronomer sailed to Acadia on a ship confiscated from Nicolas Fouquet. He spen...

9 min read
Before Nolan's Cross: Temple Beeld Cross

Before Nolan's Cross: Temple Beeld Cross

On a hilltop in the North Yorkshire Moors, on documented Templar land, stands a formation of five...

10 min read
The Oak Island Star Map

The Oak Island Star Map

Five independent researchers, using different methods and starting from different assumptions, ha...

12 min read
The Inscribed Marker Stones of Seborga

The Inscribed Marker Stones of Seborga

In the hills above the Italian Riviera, 34 inscribed boundary stones surround the village of Sebo...

9 min read

Down-to-Earth Theories

Not every theory involves treasure.

The Natural Formation Theory

The Natural Formation Theory

What if there is no treasure on Oak Island? A persistent counter-theory holds that the Money Pit is not a man-made shaft at all, but a natural sinkhole formed by the dissolution of the limestone an...

9 min read
Mi'kmaq, the First Nation

Mi'kmaq, the First Nation

Before the Money Pit, before the first European ship entered Mahone Bay, the Mi'kmaq were there. ...

9 min read
Black Gold: The Tar Kiln Theory

Black Gold: The Tar Kiln Theory

What if the Money Pit was never a vault at all, but a furnace? Researcher Joy A. Steele and marin...

12 min read
The Prize

What Lies Beneath?

A five-foot golden candelabrum from Solomon's Temple. The Ark of the Covenant. Shakespeare's lost manuscripts sealed in mercury. Each theory implies a different prize. The evidence supports more than one.

Explore the Treasure