Frequently Asked Questions
Everything you want to know about Oak Island's 231-year mystery
The Basics
Essential questions about Oak Island and its famous mystery
The Money Pit
Questions about the original discovery and the mysterious shaft
The Treasure
What might be buried and the theories behind it
The Search
The ongoing hunt and those who have pursued it
The Oak Island curse is a modern legend claiming that seven men must die before the island's treasure can be found. According to the prophecy, six treasure hunters have already perished during excavations, leaving one death supposedly required before the mystery can be solved.
The curse has become inseparable from Oak Island's identity, repeatedly referenced in documentaries, books, and especially the History Channel's The Curse of Oak Island series. The show's title itself emphasizes this dark legend, with episodes frequently reminding viewers that the island sits "one death away" from revealing its secrets.
Despite its prominence in popular culture, the curse's origins remain murky. No written record of this prophecy exists before the 1970s, and it appears nowhere in the extensive documentation from the 1795 discovery or the 19th-century expeditions that followed. The legend seems to have emerged sometime between the tragic 1965 deaths of four men in a single day and Leonard Nimoy's 1979 television special In Search Of..., which described it as "a local legend."
Whether the curse represents genuine folklore, a psychological phenomenon born from repeated tragedy, or simply effective marketing, it has proven remarkably powerful. The unfalsifiable nature of the prophecy - it can neither be proven nor disproven until the treasure is found - ensures it remains a compelling part of the Oak Island mystery.
The true origin of the "seven must die" curse remains one of Oak Island's unsolved mysteries. Despite extensive research, no documented evidence of this prophecy exists before the 1970s - nearly 180 years after treasure hunting began in 1795.
The Timeline of Emergence:
The curse appears to have crystallized following the August 17, 1965 tragedy, when Robert Restall Sr., his son Robert Jr., Karl Graeser, and Cyril Hiltz all died in a single day after succumbing to hydrogen sulfide fumes in a shaft. This devastating incident brought international media attention to Oak Island and may have planted the seeds for the curse legend.
The first documented reference appears in Leonard Nimoy's 1979 television episode of In Search Of..., where Nimoy states: "A local legend says the mysterious treasure of Oak Island will be found only when seven lives have been lost." Notably, he offers no source for this "local legend," and researchers have been unable to locate any earlier written record.
Some researchers attribute the curse to Nova Scotia folklorist Dr. Helen Creighton, who documented regional ghost stories and legends. However, careful examination of her published works - Folklore of Lunenburg County (1950) and Bluenose Ghosts (1957) - reveals no mention of a specific "seven must die" curse, though she did record general beliefs about Oak Island being haunted.
The curse likely emerged organically in treasure hunting literature of the 1970s, perhaps as a way to make sense of the tragedies or to add dramatic weight to the ongoing search. By the time the History Channel launched The Curse of Oak Island in 2014, the legend was firmly established - whether authentic folklore or modern mythology.
What remains clear is this: the curse appeared sometime between 1965 and 1979, and no historical documentation places it any earlier, despite Oak Island's 230-year history of excavation.
Six people have died during Oak Island treasure hunting operations, all in industrial accidents typical of 19th and 20th-century mining work. These were not mysterious deaths - they resulted from the inherent dangers of deep excavation, primitive safety equipment, and the engineering challenges of working on the island.
The Documented Deaths:
1861 - Unnamed Worker: The first recorded fatality occurred when a boiler exploded during operations by the Oak Island Association. The worker's name has been lost to history, but the incident reflects the dangerous steam-powered equipment of the era.
1897 - Maynard Kaiser: A worker fell to his death while working in one of the deep shafts. Falling was a constant risk in excavations that often exceeded 100 feet in depth with minimal safety precautions.
August 17, 1965 - The Restall Tragedy: This single day claimed four lives in Oak Island's worst disaster. Robert Restall Sr. descended into a shaft not knowing his crew had inadvertently broken into a pocket of hydrogen sulfide gas - a colorless, toxic gas that causes immediate unconsciousness. When Robert lost consciousness at the bottom of the shaft, his 24-year-old son Bobby descended to save him, also succumbing to the gas. Two workers, Karl Graeser and Cyril Hiltz, attempted rescue and met the same fate. Only Andy DeMont, who tried to help but was pulled back, survived. All four men died despite rescue efforts.
The 1965 tragedy devastated the treasure hunting community and brought intense media scrutiny to Oak Island. It's widely believed that this event inspired or accelerated the creation of the "seven must die" legend.
The Curse Claim: The popular prophecy that "seven must die before the treasure is found" has no historical basis. This phrase first appeared in treasure hunting literature of the 1970s and was popularized by Leonard Nimoy's 1979 In Search Of... television special. No written record of this curse exists before the 20th century - not in the 1795 discovery accounts, not in 19th-century excavation records, and not in early 20th-century documentation.
These six deaths represent real human tragedies - men who risked their lives pursuing a mystery. They deserve to be remembered for their courage and sacrifice, not as fulfillment of a modern legend with no historical foundation.
The Show
About The Curse of Oak Island TV series
Visiting Oak Island
Information for those wanting to see the island